Thursday, November 19, 2026

What’s Next For Cole Karter?

Cole Karter
Cole Karter

“The saddest thing in life is wasted talent” -A Bronx Tale, 1993

Chazz Palminteri’s semi-autobiographical one-man show played off-Broadway in 1989 before it was seen by Robert De Niro, who made his directorial debut when the narrative was released on the big screen in 1993. Chazz’s real-life story of a murder that he witnessed in his youth and growing up in the Bronx during the racial tensions of the 1960s became the foundation of the coming-of-age story that served as his breakout role in film. Chszz’s father, Lorenzo was actually a bus driver in the neighborhood, which De Niro played in the film, opposite of Palminteri himself in the role of local mafia boss, Sonny.

The street saga covers the clash between Sonny and Lorenzo, both very different men that taught the youngster in the film, Cee very different, but equally valuable lessons at the movie’s conclusion. More than anything, things come full circle with a common thread between the advice from both men.

“The saddest thing in life is wasted talent” is a theme that has always stayed with me since I watched the film originally when I was in middle school with my dad on a VHS tape (remember those?) when he recorded the film from HBO. The mob drama has everything from the harsh realities of life to a love story. Maybe our differences are only skin deep after all? As I said, that phrase about wasted talent has stayed with me for the past few decades, so much so that I have it tattooed on the inside of my right arm.

In my opinion, there’s a lot to be taken from it beyond just the surface value. Talent is rare and if that talent is wasted, it’s a wasted opportunity. That opportunity is something that others might not have ever had the talent for, and if they did, they might’ve not been given the chance to apply it. We could go down a list of numerous athletes or entertainers that didn’t get a chance to live up to their fullest potential because illness or injury detailed their careers.

To waste talent is to throw away that opportunity. Taking yourself out of the game almost thumbs your nose at those that are just as dedicated, but never got the chance. Within the world of professional wrestling, there were guys like Reckless Youth, who was a worker with an indy buzz before the term really existed. He just wasn’t at the right place at the right time to get a major run. Brag Armstrong was one of the smoothest workers in the history of the business, but only the most die hard purists of the sport can appreciate how good he really was. Bobby Eaton racked up a lot of miles on his body through incredible bumps, and you simply won’t find a subpar Eaton match. He passed away at 62 without ever truly getting the recognition or the compensation that he deserved.

That’s why it was very disappointing to read the news that Ring Of Honor performer, Cole Karter was fired after he missed a set of television tapings. Fightful Select reported that the 26-year-old was cut from the promotion after it was discovered that he lied about a family matter to have an excuse not to work the scheduled shows. There were conflicting reports since the initial story made the rounds online, but no direct denials either.

There have been no public comments made from either side so unless Sean Ross Sapp got it completely wrong, which is possible, it appears that there’s credibility to the story since it hasn’t been denied either. Unfortunately, given Cole’s track record, there probably is some validity to this story. He was actually signed to a WWE developmental deal in March of 2022, less than two years after he started in the sport, and had briefly appeared on NXT TV before he was released from the company for a reported Wellness Policy violation in June. His WWE tenure lasted just three months.

He signed with All Elite Wrestling just a few weeks later and has spent the past four years under contract, mostly under the ROH banner. Yes, ROH is more or less the witness protection program in terms of exposure, and I still don’t see a point for its existence under the ownership of Tony Khan since the video library is still the most valuable asset from the Sinclair sale, but for Cole Karter, he should be thrilled that it was an option for him, especially so quickly after he got fired from the biggest company in the world.

Cole Karter is a guy that broke into the business in the Pittsburgh area, and while I haven’t met him, many of my friends worked with him during his abbreviated time on the independent scene. The overwhelming consensus was that the youngster checked all the boxes for a potential star in the industry. He has the size, the look, and the God given athleticism to land a national contract so it wasn’t a major surprise when he did. You hear the war stories from many, including those at the highest positions in the industry now, of the times that they had to grind it out on the independent circuit for years before they made a full-time living in pro wrestling. They risked their bodies to try to get noticed and did so for relatively meager pay without any guarantees that any of it would pay off with the financial security of a major contract. For example, TNA’s Agent Zero, Bill Collier, who I’ve had the chance to do commentary for a handful of matches before he signed with Impact, was more than ready for television for at least a decade before it happened.

Thankfully for Cole Karter, he had the talent and the opportunity to skip the grind. Yes, the struggle can build character, but at some point being miserable is just being miserable with the hope that there’s eventually a payoff to it all. In theory, it’s a good thing that a youngster gets a chance to make it to the big leagues without struggling. NXT’s Thea Hail started her training around Pittsburgh with Ryse Wrestling and only had three matches before the WWE noticed her. Obviously, she’s doing very well in NXT, learning the finer points of the craft from some of the best minds in the history of the business. That’s a rare opportunity that she’s making the most of.

For Cole Karter to last three months in NXT was puzzling, but things happen, and while his career has been relatively quiet for the past four years in All Elite, he’s a young wrestler getting paid a fill-time living while he gets valuable television experience that he can either use to move up the ladder in AEW or eventually apply it elsewhere,

As I said, I don’t know him personally so I’m not going to make any judgements about if it’s within his real-life character to supposedly fabricate a reason not to work a ROH taping, but hypothetically, if that was the case, it’s an extremely disappointing waste of talent. Maybe he thought it wasn’t worth working the shows because ROH is a smaller platform? But, the entire point of the business is to make as much money as possible so unless there was a legitimate family emergency, why not continue to get paid? Kater was signed to a contract by a billionaire, I’m not saying he could buy a mansion with ROH money, but he wasn’t working for $20 and the left over hotdogs at the concession stand either.

I have to be honest, considering that Tony Khan usually lets contracts expire if he doesn’t plan to re-sign someone instead of cut them from the roster so that they can get paid as much as possible before they exit the company, it actually takes effort to get fired by AEW, which makes me think this could be an accurate report from Fightful Select.

At this point, Cole Karter must decide if he actually wants to be a professional wrestler, and if he doesn’t, there’s nothing wrong with that. If he wants to continue in the business, the decisions that he makes going forward are key. If he wants to continue in the business, his career isn’t over, depending on where he goes from here. This could boil down to the notion of “too much too soon,” which isn’t uncommon in the sport in the past so there’s a chance that management would be willing to give a second chance in the future. Tony Atlas, Teddy Hart, and Randy Orton all had the same problem in different generations. Make no mistake about it, if Randy’s last name was different, he would’ve been axed from the roster at some point. Teddy Hart got a second chance because of his last name and still fumbled it. Tony Atlas is still wrestling today to make ends meet.

At 26, Cole Karter still has an opportunity to redirect his career trajectory, and it’s more than possible that three or four years from now, his story is completely different, especially taking into account how much talent he legitimately has. The fact that he already worked for both of the national companies by this point in his career proves that he has the tools to be on that stage. Where he goes right now, if anywhere, could determine where he eventually ends up. I could be wrong, but I’d say the NXT door is still shut until he proves himself elsewhere. If he lied to AEW, he burned the bridge, there are simply too many other prospects that can take his place for the office to be concerned with developing him as a commodity any further.

That being said, if he can land a deal with Major League Wrestling or maybe even Game Changer Wrestling, somewhere with enough viability that the WWE at least has eyes on it, it’s more than possible that he can be offered another NXT contract. The ability to show consistent quality and reliability is key if he wants to continue his career.

Chazz Palminteri is right, the saddest thing in life is wasted talent.

Until next week
-Jim LaMotta

E mail [email protected] | You can follow me on Instagram, Facebook, & Threads @jimlamotta89